· CostMyTokens · Analysis · 9 min read

Claude vs GPT-6 API Pricing: Same Headline Prices, Different Meters

Claude vs GPT-6 API pricing: Fable/Astra $10/$50, Sonnet/Sol $2/$10, Haiku/Luna $0.10/$0.50 — ties on sticker, gaps on long context, cache and exclusive rungs.

Quick answer: At the three tiers most teams actually buy, Anthropic and OpenAI charge identical headline prices: $10 input / $50 output per million tokens at the top (Claude Fable 5.1 vs GPT-6 Astra), $2 / $10 in the workhorse tier (Claude Sonnet 5.5 vs GPT-6.1 Sol), and $0.10 / $0.50 at the budget tier (Claude Haiku 5.5 vs GPT-6 Luna). The real differences are in the metering: OpenAI reprices whole requests once a prompt passes 272K tokens, Anthropic holds standard rates across a full 1M context (except on Haiku), Fable’s cache reads are four times cheaper than Astra’s, and OpenAI sells an extra mid-tier rung — GPT-6.1 Terra at $1/$5 — that Anthropic has no answer to. Prices in US dollars, verified against Anthropic’s and OpenAI’s official pricing pages on November 3, 2026.

Disclosure: this article contains no affiliate links. Where CostMyTokens does use affiliate links elsewhere, they never affect order — every table is sorted by price only. Read our disclosure.

The two lineups, side by side

Standard rates per 1M tokens, short-context pricing:

TierClaude modelInputCached readOutputGPT modelInputCached readOutput
Top flagshipFable 5.1$10$0.25$50GPT-6 Astra$10$1.00$50
FlagshipOpus 5.5$4$0.20$20————
WorkhorseSonnet 5.5$2$0.10$10GPT-6.1 Sol$2$0.10$10
Extra rung————GPT-6.1 Terra$1$0.05$5
BudgetHaiku 5.5$0.10$0.01$0.50GPT-6 Luna$0.10$0.01$0.50

Two structural notes before the tier-by-tier detail. First, each vendor has one rung the other lacks: Anthropic splits its upper range into Opus ($4/$20) and Sonnet ($2/$10), while OpenAI inserts Terra ($1/$5) between its workhorse and budget tiers. Second, the original GPT-6 Sol also lists at $2/$10 but with a shallower $0.20 cached rate; the current workhorse is GPT-6.1 Sol, which is the one compared here. Full rate cards are in our Claude API pricing guide and OpenAI API pricing guide; for the three-way picture including Google, see OpenAI vs Anthropic vs Google pricing.

What each tier costs on a standard workload

Our standard workload — 10M tokens a month at an 8:2 input/output split, standard rates, no caching:

PairingClaudeGPT-6Verdict
Top flagshipFable 5.1: $180Astra: $180Exact tie
Flagship vs workhorseOpus 5.5: $72GPT-6.1 Sol: $36OpenAI half — but the honest Claude comparator at $36 is Sonnet
WorkhorseSonnet 5.5: $36GPT-6.1 Sol: $36Exact tie
Extra rung—Terra: $18OpenAI-only price point
BudgetHaiku 5.5: $1.80Luna: $1.80Exact tie

On sticker price alone, this comparison would be three ties and a footnote. Everything interesting happens in the four sections below.

Difference 1: long prompts — OpenAI reprices, Anthropic doesn’t

This is the largest structural difference between the two rate cards.

  • OpenAI: once a request’s input passes 272K tokens, the entire request is repriced: input and cached input at 2x, output at 1.5x. On GPT-6.1 Sol that means $4/$15 instead of $2/$10; on Astra, $20/$75.
  • Anthropic: models from Claude 4.6 onward — Fable 5.1, Opus 5.5 and Sonnet 5.5 included — carry the full 1M-token context at standard pricing. A 900K-token request bills at the same per-token rate as a 9K one, and caching and Batch discounts apply across the whole window.

Worked example, a 500K-input / 10K-output request on the workhorse tier: Sonnet 5.5 costs $1.10 (0.5M × $2 + 0.01M × $10). The same request on GPT-6.1 Sol costs $2.15 (0.5M × $4 + 0.01M × $15) because every token crossed the threshold with it. For long-document, codebase-scale or RAG workloads that routinely pass 272K input tokens, Anthropic’s flat pricing is worth roughly a 2x input discount that never appears in headline tables.

The budget tier flips the pattern. Haiku 5.5 is the one Claude model with length-based pricing: prompts over 100K tokens pay $0.50/$2.50 — five times its base rates — with prompt length counted per request, cache reads and writes included. Luna’s threshold is higher (272K) and its uplift gentler ($0.20/$0.75). Under 100K both cost the same; between 100K and 272K of prompt, Luna is the cheaper budget model by a wide margin.

Difference 2: caching — Fable’s reads are in a class of their own

Both vendors now charge for cache writes at 1.25x the input rate on their standard retention tier (Anthropic: 5-minute TTL at 1.25x, 1-hour at 2x; OpenAI: 30-minute at 1.25x, 12-hour at 2.5x), and both discount cache reads — but by very different depths at the top:

  • Fable 5.1 reads cost $0.25 — 0.025x of input, a special rate Anthropic gives only to its top tier. Opus 5.5 and Sonnet 5.5 read at 0.05x ($0.20 / $0.10).
  • Astra reads cost $1.00 — the standard 0.1x. GPT-6.1 Sol matches Sonnet at $0.10 (0.05x); Terra reads at $0.05; Luna and Haiku tie at $0.01.

Run the standard workload with half the input served from cache (4M fresh + 4M cached reads + 2M output, write charges excluded*):

PairingClaudeGPT-6
Top flagshipFable 5.1: $141Astra: $144
WorkhorseSonnet 5.5: $28.40GPT-6.1 Sol: $28.40
BudgetHaiku 5.5: $1.44Luna: $1.44

The workhorse and budget tiers stay tied to the cent. Only at the top does caching separate them: agent loops that re-read long system prompts and tool definitions every call pay 4x less per cached token on Fable than on Astra, which compounds into a small but real monthly gap ($141 vs $144 here, wider the more cache-heavy the workload). Our API cost calculator lets you set the cached share for your own mix.

* Site convention: cached scenarios count reads only. The first write of any cached block costs 1.25x input at both vendors and amortises across reads.

Difference 3: Batch and speed tiers are a wash

  • Batch: both vendors take 50% off input and output for asynchronous processing (Anthropic’s Batch API; OpenAI’s Batch/Flex). On the standard workload that is $90 vs $90 at the top, $18 vs $18 in the workhorse tier, $0.90 vs $0.90 at the budget tier — the ties survive every discount both sides publish.
  • Speed: both sell a roughly 2x fast lane (Anthropic’s Fast mode prices Opus 5.5 at $8/$40; OpenAI’s Fast mode costs twice Standard). Neither side gains a price edge by going faster.
  • Data residency: both add about 10% for region-pinned processing (Anthropic’s US inference option is 1.1x on current models; OpenAI’s regional processing endpoints carry a 10% uplift). Another tie.

Difference 4: the rungs only one vendor sells

  • Opus 5.5 at $4/$20 is Anthropic’s bet that a tier exists between “best” and “workhorse”: on the standard workload it costs exactly double Sonnet ($72 vs $36) and 2.5x less than Fable. OpenAI’s nearest offers are Astra at 2.5x Opus’s price or 6.1 Sol at half — there is no $4/$20 GPT-6.
  • GPT-6.1 Terra at $1/$5 is the mirror image: $18 on the standard workload, $14.20 with 50% caching — a price point Anthropic’s ladder skips entirely (its steps go $36 straight to $1.80). For teams routing mixed traffic, Terra is the tier that makes a three-level routing ladder (Terra → Sol → Astra) cheaper to run than a two-level one.

A necessary caveat: a token is not a token

Per-token prices compare cleanly only if both tokenizers count your text the same way, and they don’t. Anthropic notes that Claude 4.7 and later models (and Mythos Preview) use a newer tokenizer that produces roughly 30% more tokens for the same text than earlier Claude models; OpenAI uses its own counting again. Treat every figure here as the rate card, not a promise about your bill — the only honest test is running the same workload on both and comparing invoices, which is what the per-model calculators on the Anthropic and OpenAI provider pages are for.

Verdict: pick by workload shape, not by sticker

  • Long-context work (prompts regularly over 272K): Claude, on flat 1M pricing — the gap is structural, about 2x on input for affected requests. Exception: at the budget tier, keep prompts under 100K on Haiku or use Luna.
  • Cache-heavy agent loops at the top tier: Fable 5.1, for the 0.025x cache read no OpenAI model matches.
  • Everything in the workhorse and budget tiers: a genuine tie on price — $36, $28.40 cached, $1.80, $1.44. Choose on model quality, tooling and ecosystem; price will not separate Sonnet 5.5 from GPT-6.1 Sol or Haiku 5.5 from GPT-6 Luna.
  • Mixed routing fleets: OpenAI’s extra Terra rung gives a cheaper middle step; Anthropic’s Opus gives a cheaper step down from the flagship. Which ladder fits depends on whether your traffic concentrates in the middle or at the top.

FAQ

Is Claude or GPT-6 cheaper? At headline rates, neither: the top ($10/$50), workhorse ($2/$10) and budget ($0.10/$0.50) tiers are priced identically. Costs separate on long prompts (Anthropic is flat, OpenAI reprices past 272K), on top-tier cache reads (Fable is cheaper), and on the two exclusive rungs — Opus 5.5 at $4/$20 and GPT-6.1 Terra at $1/$5.

Which is cheapest for high-volume, low-complexity work? A tie: Haiku 5.5 and GPT-6 Luna both run $1.80 on our standard workload, $1.44 with half the input cached, and $0.90 on Batch. Watch Haiku’s over-100K-prompt pricing ($0.50/$2.50) if your “simple” calls carry long prompts.

Who charges extra for long prompts? OpenAI does, past 272K input tokens: the whole request moves to 2x input and 1.5x output rates. Anthropic charges standard rates across the full 1M window on Fable, Opus and Sonnet; only Haiku 5.5 has length-based pricing, above 100K tokens.

Are Batch discounts the same on both? Yes — 50% off input and output at both vendors, on every model compared here.

Why can my bill differ even at identical per-token prices? Tokenizers differ: the same text produces different token counts on each platform (Anthropic’s Claude 4.7+ tokenizer counts roughly 30% more tokens than earlier Claude models). Identical rate cards can still produce different invoices; compare on a real workload sample.

Full rate cards: Claude API pricing, Claude Opus 5.5 API Pricing, GPT-6 API pricing and OpenAI API pricing. Three-way view including Google: OpenAI vs Anthropic vs Google pricing. Provider catalogs: Anthropic and OpenAI.

Prices verified against Anthropic’s official pricing documentation and OpenAI’s official API pricing page on November 3, 2026. Both vendors state prices in USD per million tokens and reserve the right to change them. This comparison covers the current flagship families only; legacy models and promotional rates (such as GPT-5.6 Sol’s) are tracked on the provider pages.

Share:
Back to Blog

Related Posts

View All Posts »